SmartTube vs YouTube Premium
YouTube Premium is Google's paid subscription tier that removes ads, enables background playback on mobile, and provides offline downloads, at approximately $13.99 per month. SmartTube is a free, MIT-licensed Android TV app that delivers ad-free YouTube viewing on Android-based TV devices with additional playback controls the official app does not include.
| Feature | SmartTube | YouTube Premium |
|---|
| Price | Free | ~$13.99/month |
| License | MIT | Proprietary |
| Ad-free viewing | Yes | Yes |
| SponsorBlock | Yes | No |
| Adjustable playback speed | Yes (TV) | Limited |
| 8K resolution | Yes | Yes |
| HDR | Yes | Yes |
| Background audio (mobile) | No | Yes |
| Offline downloads | No | Yes |
| Works on non-Android TVs | No | Yes |
| App store install | No (sideload) | Yes |
SmartTube is the better choice for Android TV households that watch YouTube daily. It delivers SponsorBlock, 8K playback, and fine-grained speed controls that YouTube Premium does not provide, at no recurring cost. The one-time APK sideload is a low bar for the ongoing savings, and the built-in updater handles future releases.
YouTube Premium is the better choice when viewing spans multiple device types. A household watching YouTube across phones, tablets, web browsers, and non-Android TVs benefits from the single-subscription coverage that YouTube Premium provides across all those surfaces. Background audio playback and offline downloads on mobile are YouTube Premium features SmartTube does not offer. If viewing is split between TV and mobile, the platform coverage of YouTube Premium justifies its cost.